Eddie by Giddy costs $188-$288. Xialla costs $50-$89. Both sit in the stretch ring aisle. The useful question is which constraint you will live with, not which homepage is louder.
Neither page on the internet can wear the device for you. Fit, and whether a stretch silicone ring is actually your problem, decide more than the brand.
At a glance
| Eddie by Giddy | Xialla | |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | $188-$288 | $50-$89 |
| Material | firm elastomer, open underside | stretch silicone plus a tether and adhesive pad |
| Sizing | four widths, A through D, with a resizing policy | anchored fit; less dependent on a tight inner diameter |
| Medical-device listing | maker says yes | maker says yes |
| HSA/FSA (maker’s claim) | claimed | not claimed |
| Vibration | no | no |
| Anaesthetic | no | no |
| Best for | men who want a medical-device purchase, HSA billing, or who found circular rings painful on the urethra | men told they have venous leak who lose the erection during movement |
| Not for | men who have not yet tested whether any constriction helps | men who want a ring they can put on in the dark with one hand |
Prices for other brands are approximate and move. Ours are the store listing.
Price
Xialla is the cheaper of the two as listed. kit $50 including 10 pads on xialla.com as of 2026-09-16; 40-pad refill $39. Confirm the other at source before you treat this as a quote.
How they actually work
Eddie by Giddy: constriction that Giddy says leaves the urethra and underside arteries less compressed Xialla: holds the ring and scrotum back so the ring does not roll forward during thrusting
Sizing
Eddie by Giddy sizing: four widths, A through D, with a resizing policy. Xialla: anchored fit; less dependent on a tight inner diameter.
Regulatory sticker
Both are sold with medical-device positioning. Listing is not the same as FDA approval of effectiveness. See each maker’s own language.
Who should buy Eddie by Giddy
men who want a medical-device purchase, HSA billing, or who found circular rings painful on the urethra. Strengths the maker can honestly claim: Class II listing; HSA/FSA eligibility stated by Giddy; sized system; company-cited 12-week trial. Limits: several times the price of a silicone set; still cannot create an erection from nothing.
Who should buy Xialla
men told they have venous leak who lose the erection during movement. Strengths: venous-leak positioning; published IJIR paper on the design; works flaccid or erect per the maker. Limits: adhesive pad and strap are extra steps; you are buying a system, not a ring in a drawer.
The cheaper test from this shop
You do not have to pick Eddie by Giddy or Xialla on the first order. Red Tiger or Mammoth Ring ($24.99 / $39.99) is the Mammoth Force version of this job: a stretch silicone ring. If a $25–$50 product shows you the mechanism does nothing for you, you have not spent $188-$288 or $50-$89 finding that out.
Mammoth Force
Red Tiger
Three silicone rings. The store does not publish inner diameters.
4.6 from 15,000+ reviews
Free shipping over $50 • Discreet packaging • Ships from Huntington Beach, CA
Mammoth Force
Mammoth Ring
Stretch silicone ring. Store lists oval inner size 1.5 in and a 2.5x stretch.
4.6 from 15,000+ reviews
Free shipping over $50 • Discreet packaging • Ships from Huntington Beach, CA
Safety
The Mammoth, Dragon and Red Tiger product pages say thirty minutes maximum and never while sleeping. Remove at once on numbness, pain, coldness or a dark colour change.
What to read next
- Sizing if this is a ring
- stretch rings we sell
- In-house ring comparison if you already picked this shop